Up – Film Review

Adventure of LifetimeWhat is the definition of story? My answer is “conflict.” Great stories unfold against a backdrop of tension and combine reality and fantasy. Pixar Animation Studios has mastered this formula for kids and grown-ups alike. Their latest work, Up, tracks the life of Carl Fredricksen (Ed Asner) from the time he was a little boy watching newsreel footage of an explorer he idolized, through his marriage with Ellie (Ellie Docter), and finally on to his life’s adventure of visiting a lost world.

They makers of Up borrowed a very effective device from Wall-E by taking us through a significant portion of the story without dialogue. In Up it was a more straightforward, Hollywood style approach meant to define Carl’s character and show us the arc of his life. He had great dreams of adventure, but acted on them much later than he had planned.

Carl has held onto his home which is now in the center of a high-rise construction site. He won’t give it up, but when circumstances force him to leave, he uses his experience as a balloon salesman to inflate thousands of them with helium and levitate his home high in the air. It’s South America or bust. All is going well until a young scout named Russell (Jordan Nagai), looking for one final merit badge, has stowed away and is now on the same journey.

The usual challenges arise along the way, but also some unexpected ones. Talking dogs, an exotic bird and finally, a nail-biting, unplanned battle that Carl is forced to fight in order to do what’s right as well as accomplish his life long dream.

CarlPixar pulls on the heartstrings but immediately lets them go with wonderful moments of humor for the parents as well as the kids. It’s full of clever dialogue. Director Pete Docter and co-director Bob Peterson are clearly in command, setting a brisk pace and giving us lots to look at along the way. They weave it all together in predictable ways, but do it so cleverly that you don’t mind not being blown away with some stock turn of events. It’s high adventure, and probably the most grown up story Pixar has turned out yet. Many of their films deal with inevitable events like death, but this one puts people in the center of the story. Wall-E had people, but come on, is that where mankind is going? I didn’t buy it. Up makes it “human real” and immediately relatable for young and old alike. In my view it could be the beginning of a new framework for Pixar. But there is so much pressure to produce box office, they will likely be forced to pursue whatever they think will sell tickets. I understand. We’ll see.

I viewed this film in 3D and really didn’t find it more interesting or exciting. They don’t over trick the viewer, but I found the experience to be not as big or bright as a regular 35MM print, and many of the 3D effects blended into my brain over time. I actually wish I had not seen it in 3D. I’ll be watching with interest to see if 3D is a phase or the future. I explore this further in an earlier post here.

I enthusiastically recommend this picture for all. Providing they are ready for PG films. The official Up web site is full of fun and energy. Be sure and visit here.


  1. Hi Steve,
    Thanks for the review of the 3D version. I saw Up in 2D version and it sounds like I didn’t miss anything. In fact, one thing I noticed was that with this film, there was more of a focus on story and character, and less emphasis on animation wizardry, than in other digitally animated films. When watching digitized furry animals, for example, I usually get hypnotized staring at individually articulated hairs billowing in the animated wind and stop listening to the dialogue. Not in this picture. The animation served the story, not the other way around.

    So the movie serves as a reminder for those of us who think about designing a good user experience: Just because you can blow customers away with eye candy, doesn’t mean you should. Focus on your story.

  2. Steve, Great hearing from you! You are dead on with your comments. I am going to pass on all 3D from now on. Ice Age 3 is coming and we will be watching it old school. Had lunch with Linda C. today. Hope all is well with your venture. Really appreciate you visiting, reading and commenting.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s